Summary:
In Harry M. Benshoff’s article “The Monster and the Homosexual”, Benshoff discusses the relationship between the homosexual and the monster. According to Benshoff, the concept of “homosexuals” and “monster” arouse many of the same fears in people about sex and death. This was especially true in the time of the AIDS crisis. Viewed similar to vampires in a horror film, gay men where seen as contagious and with single mingling of blood, a pure innocent person became victim to this disease just as with vampires, the person would become the undead. According to Robin Wood, monsters can be viewed as racial, ethnic, and/or political/ideological Others or as sexual Others (women, bisexuals, and homosexuals). The term “queer” is discussed and identified as what someone who doesn’t explicitly define themselves in a “traditional” homosexual term. The queer, according to a theorist, “revels in the discourse of the loathsome, the outcast, the idiomatically proscribed position of same-sex desire.” Further into the article, Benshoff discusses the role reversal involving homosexual characters. A gay male normally takes on more of a feminine side where as a lesbian character typically becomes more masculine. This idea is similar to the idea of phallicization from Carol Clover’s article. There are four ways that homosexuality might intersect with the horror film. The first is when horror films contain identifiably gay and/or lesbian characters. The second is a horror film that is written, produced, or directed by a gay man or lesbian. The third is through subtextual or connotative avenues. The fourth is through the sense that any film viewed by gay or lesbian spectators might be considered queer, so through the audience.
Analysis:
In Jack Sholder’s A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge, the audience sees homosexuality intersect with the horror genre through a subtext avenue (Benshoff’s article) and stereotypical homosexual male traits. The homosexual subtext in this film suggests that the main character, Jesse struggles with his sexuality even though the audience sees him in a heterosexual relationship with Lisa. The audience sees Jesse’s feminine nature in many scenes. For example, in the scene where Jesse is unpacking his bedroom after he’s moved on Elm Street. As he starts to “clean” and “unpack” he puts on a tape of girly music, puts on some glittery sunglasses, and dances around his bedroom until Lisa comes over and interrupts him. The audience also sees his feminine side when Jesse and Freddy meet face to face. Jesse becomes terrified and screams in a high-pitched girl-like way.

The audience sees Jesse’s repressed sexuality emerge when Freddy is “inside” of him. At Lisa’s party, when Jesse and Lisa are being intimate, a creepy, long, purple tongue comes from Jesse’s mouth and licks Lisa. This is Freddy’s way of trying to block Jesse’s heterosexual relationship with Lisa and get inside Jesse (Benshoff’s article). Jesse quickly gets up and runs away. After not being able to perform sexually with a female because of Freddy, he seeks comfort and help from his male best friend. Later in this scene, as Freddy is taking over Jesse’s body and attacking Ron, the film shows Freddy physically “coming out” of Jesse. This could be a symbolic “coming out” just as a homosexual person would “come out” as gay. The audience also sees the repression of Jesse’s sexuality (Benshoff’s article) when he is trying to keep Freddy from coming out and hurting Lisa. Jesse says, “There is something trying to get inside my body”, “he’s inside me” and “he wants to take me again” all while Lisa is trying to get Jesse to fight Freddy and to not let him come out. This symbolizes how some homosexual individuals may feel while coming to terms with who they are. Some may want to represses their homosexual urges but they can not.

The audience sees another example of the homosexual and the monster in the sadistic gym teacher, Mr. Schnieder. In the film, it is revealed that Mr. Schnieder likes to hangout at “a queer S & M joint” and that he “likes pretty boys” which suggests he is gay. Although Mr. Schnieder is not the main monster in the film, he plays a role in making Jesse and Rons’ lives miserable during school. He forces the boys to do pushups outside until their arms are weak and wobbly. Later in the film, when Jesse leaves his house after another nightmare, he is caught drinking a beer by none other than Mr. Schnieder dressed in a promiscuous leather outfit. Schnieder then forces Jesse to run laps in the gym and then shower. As Jesse showers, a mysterious force ties Mr.Schneider up with jump ropes in the showers facing the wall, rips off his clothes, and spanks him repeatedly with a towel all while Jesse watches. Freddy Krueger then makes his first appearance in the real world and kills Schnieder with his sharp blade fingers.

Overall, this film contains many different forms of gay subtext and the monster and the homosexual while demonstrating sexual repression and horror.

















